I Hate It Here

Your Small Business Might Be Closer to Offering a 401(k) Than You Think: Start With These 5 Steps

5 easy steps to follow to get prepared to offer and set up a 401(k)

Hebba Youssef · NOV 16

Sponsored by: Betterment

Still researching 401(k)s, eh? Betterment at Work can walk you through setup!

Put those tabs to rest

Paid non-client. Views may not be representative. See G2 reviews. Learn more.

How many good candidates can you afford to lose before offering a 401(k) feels like a no-brainer? 👀

Maybe your founder has decided to start looking into it (which is wonderful news), but that also includes one big ol’ to-do list item:

Now you get to figure out what it costs and which providers to call, which honestly may leave you with more questions than answers, depending on how deep you’re going down the rabbit hole!

I’ve worked for 4 venture-backed startups, so I get why this gets pushed off. There’s always something that feels more urgent…

…Until a candidate asks about retirement benefits and instead, you’ve pivoted to explaining how much opportunity there is to grow with the company.

(A person can appreciate the opportunity and still really want a 401(k), ya know!)

The research phase can wear you out before you’ve even requested a quote, and you’re not alone if you’ve ever experienced this kind of fatigue.

🫩 Every explanation sends you to another explanation, and eventually you’re reading about nondiscrimination testing and wondering how much of this you’re personally expected to learn!

The short answer is that you just need to know enough to choose a plan and understand your responsibilities.

That’s a pretty reasonable place to start, right? You can and should hire people who do this for a living to help with the rest!

✍🏽 Here are 5 easy steps to follow to get prepared to offer and set up a 401(k), so you can leave with something more useful than another browser tab.

But First…Check What’s ChangedCopy anchor linkCopied

If your company priced a retirement plan years ago and decided against it, it’s probably worth getting some fresh numbers. 🔎

BTW: SECURE 2.0 expanded tax credits that could offset some eligible expenses.

For qualifying employers with 50 or fewer employees, the startup credit may cover 100% of eligible costs, subject to an employee-based limit of up to $5,000 a year for three years. Your team’s size affects that limit, so a smaller business may qualify for less.

An eligible automatic enrollment arrangement may bring another $500 annually for three years. Some employers may also qualify for a separate contribution credit, with its own limits and phaseouts.

Before anyone spends that money in their head, have your accountant check the tax credit requirements. These credits are nonrefundable, and eligibility depends on things like employee compensation and whether you previously offered a plan.

Ask what you might qualify for and what you’d owe once the credits end!

Your state may also have requirements. Some employers must offer a qualifying retirement plan or facilitate a state program, depending on location, org size, and other rules.

You can check the requirements where you operate here if you need, and make note that a state program works differently from a 401(k), so go ahead and compare the obligations before choosing.

💡Now, consider how all of this changes the hiring convo, since a candidate could be excited about your mission, but also concerned about paying for life outside of work.

Offering a retirement benefit may help candidates feel better about joining a smaller company!

Now, onto those 5 steps!

pasted-image.png

You’ll probably hear about traditional and safe harbor 401(k)s early in the process.

Start by asking what each would mean for your budget.

A traditional plan generally gives you flexibility around employer contributions and requires annual nondiscrimination testing.

📝 Those tests check whether the plan disproportionately benefits higher-paid employees. Your provider should explain what that means for your particular workforce.

With a safe harbor plan, you commit to specified employer contributions and meet other conditions.

In return, the plan may automatically satisfy certain nondiscrimination tests, but you’d still have other compliance work to do, which is worth remembering when anything gets described as being simpler.

Ask the provider to price both options using your actual employee roster, and have them explain the contribution formulas and vesting requirements, too.

🤓 Pro tip: Have them run the numbers for a larger team as well, so you’ll know if the contribution will still be affordable if you, for example, added 10 more employees.

Personally, I’d want that answer before making a promise people will build into their financial plans, and before the founder enthusiastically announces it at an all-hands!

pasted-image.png

A provider is asking you to trust them with a benefit that involves people’s money, sooo yeah…you’re allowed to be as thorough as you wanna be!!

A plan needs recordkeeping to track accounts and transactions, admin to handle compliance work, and investment expertise.

Some providers package those services together, so I recommend asking who performs each role and what you’d still have to handle internally.

🤑 One of the discussions you’ll inevitably be covering will be around the fees! 🤑

What does setup cost?

What will the business pay each year?

What comes out of employees’ accounts?

Include investment expenses in that convo, and request a written breakdown you can compare with other proposals if you’re shopping around.

After that, I’d spend some time asking questions related to support.

So for example, if a contribution goes missing, who investigates? Can employees get help directly with account questions?

Find out the hours, too. Contact Support feels a LOT less reassuring when support is unavailable during your freaking workday. 😴

Lastly, ask which fiduciary responsibilities the provider takes on.

A 3(38) investment manager may assume responsibility for choosing and monitoring investments within the agreed scope, but you’re still responsible for prudently selecting and monitoring that provider.

I know, I know…whole lotta things to consider here, so if you leave a call confused, don’t be afraid to ask questions again!

You need to understand what you’re signing, even if the salesperson feels the urge to jump to another meeting.

pasted-image.png

🙌 Now's the part where you’ll decide who’s eligible and when they can join! 🙌

You’ll also work through employer contributions and vesting, meaning when employees own those employer contributions. Employees always own their own salary deferrals.

Your provider should help put these decisions into the plan document. Bring questions about part-time employees too, since having “part-time” in someone’s job classification doesn’t settle whether they can be excluded.

You’ll need to address automatic enrollment as well. Lots of newer plans have to enroll eligible employees at an initial contribution rate between 3% and 10%, with annual increases under applicable rules. Of course, employees can opt out or choose a different rate.

Certain businesses with 10 or fewer employees, and businesses less than 3 years old, have exceptions, so ask your provider whether one applies and when you might lose it as the business grows.

Read the automatic enrollment overview before that discussion, because you’ll give yourself room to ask the basic questions now. I think it’s considerably less stressful than discovering you misunderstood something after the announcement!

pasted-image.png

🔗 Find out exactly HOW your payroll system connects with the plan. 🔗

Being told a software can integrate is just a starting point, so I would have several follow-up questions like:

Will contribution changes update automatically? How do new hires get added? Who notices if a transfer fails? You get the idea!

Check the payroll integrations and ask what your particular connection requires from your team. If there’s a spreadsheet involved, you definitely wanna know who’s updating it.

Have the person who runs payroll join this convo, if that’s not you. They may spot a manual task or timing issue you could miss, and they deserve a say before the company buys something that adds more work to every pay period going forward.

Before the first payroll runs, be crystal clear about who checks deductions and employer contributions!

Employee deferrals have deposit deadlines, so money withheld from paychecks can’t hang around in the business account indefinitely, which means you need clear instructions on timing and corrections.

Those instructions should include an internal contact and a backup who knows the process.

Someone will eventually (hopefully) take PTO, and they should be able to enjoy it without approving a contribution file from their hotel lobby!

pasted-image.png

By this point, you’ve more than likely spent weeks getting familiar with your plan. 🗓️

Your employees are coming in fresh, and some may be opening a retirement account for the first time. cue jazz hands

Give them a little room to figure it out…it will take some time, but I’d much rather someone ask something like “What’s a match?” during enrollment than spend a whole year missing out because they felt embarrassed to ask!

So you may wanna start with the questions they’re probably already thinking: What comes out of my paycheck? What does the company contribute? And who can help if I get stuck or have questions later?

Send the required notices and enrollment info on time, with an explanation people can easily digest.

If you offer a match, show an example using your actual formula. Basically, explain vesting as simply as you can without making employees decode the plan document themselves, since you can expect questions from people who have never had access to a retirement plan before.

For automatic enrollment, tell people what percentage will come out of their pay and how to change it or opt out. They deserve to understand that before payday, after all! 🤑

Give them something short they can refer back to, including where to get account help. Cover investment risk, and leave individual investment recommendations to qualified professionals.

After launch, someone still needs to track required notices, applicable annual testing, and Form 5500 preparation and filing!

Confirm which tasks your provider handles and which need your approval. Safe harbor plans need ongoing administration, too.

And when you’ve got everything up and running, maybe a little happy dance is in order! 💃

pasted-image.png

If you’re reading all this thinking, “Okay, but when am I supposed to do any of it?” I hear you loud and clear, my friend!

Even a straightforward setup takes time, and I doubt your calendar has a suspiciously empty week for you to figure out retirement benefits casually. You should have a good idea of the time your team will need before signing.

This is where having someone walk you through the process may make it feel a lot more doable. 🤝

Betterment at Work offers plan design guidance, onboarding support, and payroll integrations that may make this more manageable for a small HR team.

Their services also include annual testing and preparing a signature-ready Form 5500. Employers still have responsibilities, so be sure to ask for the details of what’s included.

You can even start with their cost calculator before requesting a proposal for your workforce! 💡

There’s enough here to make you curious about what your best options are, so a convo with a provider may move you further than another 6 months of trying to research everything yourself.

Let’s get your future funded

Paid non-client. Views may not be representative. See G2 reviews. Learn more.

Information provided about SECURE 2.0 reflects Betterment’s current understanding and analysis but may change as additional regulatory guidance becomes available. Provisions may require plan amendments before they can be implemented. This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal or tax advice.

In collaboration with: Betterment

Your benefits package could use a future, don’t you agree?? Explore a small business 401(k) with Betterment at Work!

Meet the support

Get I Hate It Here in your inbox

A safe space for jaded, overworked and emotionally burned out HR/People Operations professionals who need a little inspiration to tackle the newest dumpster fire of the week.

Written by Hebba Youssef

I Hate It Here

A safe space for jaded, overworked and emotionally burned out HR/People Operations professionals who need a little inspiration to tackle the newest dumpster fire of the week.

By Hebba Youssef