it wasn't me
Shaggy anddd also all the orgs using AI to make decisions
HIII,
It is chillllly and I’m officially at the bring me cookies and blanket stage of the year. There are few things I love more than a cozy winter day. Give me snacks, a blanket and book and I’m in my happy place.
We’re thisclose to the end of the year where things get quiet!!! But before we get there a few things to keep on your radar:
📺 TOMORROW: Sarika Lamont and Jessica Winder join me on HR Therapy to break down where the heck our time goes in HR and how to better manage all the things on our plates. Trust me, it’s gonna be a gooood time.
🎧 The pod this week is Law & Order: HR’s Version. The incredible and super knowledgeable Val Jensen joins me to break down 3 court cases that HR folks should know about! From the ATS that declined candidates to the accommodations that were met, there’s a lottt to unpack.
🫶🏽 Pass the Thanks is still open! Write a quick note to the HR person who kept you sane this year and Safe Space will deliver it. There are only two weeks left in November, so go make someone's day??
🖥️ Safe Space Summit VIRTUAL is coming in March of 2027. I’m doing a SPEAKER CALL for folks who are interested in speaking! Here are 3 buckets I’m looking for speakers in: 1) pay & benefits, 2) performance, culture, managers or 3) AI, HR tech or the future. Interested in being a speaker??? Drop a note here and I’ll be in touch. I’m pumped to get new and fresh voices on every stage.
Nowww onto today, part two!!
ACCOUNTABILITY
AI to blame?Copy anchor linkCopied

A quick recap: last week I wrote about companies laying people off "because of AI" and then rehiring when it didn't work. AI was used as the excuse.
Today the focus is AI as the decision-maker.
And I need to introduce you to Derek Mobley. Derek is an IT professional in North Carolina. Starting in 2017, he applied to more than 100 jobs at companies using Workday's recruiting platform.
But he didn't get ONE interview.
And some of his rejections came within an hour of applying and one even showed up at 1:50 a.m., minutes after he hit submit.
Y’all what recruiters are reviewing resumes at 1:50 in the morning??? That was a hypothetical question, clearly we’re not. And if you are… please log off and go to bed.
Nobody was!!!!! That's the point!!
Some additional context: Derek is Black, over 40, and is disabled.
In February 2023, he sued Workday, alleging its AI screening tools filtered people out based on race, age, and disability. Workday denies the allegations and the case has yet to reach a verdict. This is the first course case Val and I dissect on today’s pod!!
TBH: even without a verdict, this case is already changing the rules. A LOT of HR people are already super cautious about letting AI make the decisions (as they should be!!!).
Clearly, that gut check IS right.
Because when the tool makes the call and it goes wrong, somebody has to answer for it. Right??? Well… who is that somebody? Is it the HR team or could it be the tech…
So... who's owning it?Copy anchor linkCopied

So who rejected Derek? Everybody points somewhere else. 🙃
In July 2024, Judge Rita Lin ruled that Workday could be treated as an agent of the employers using its tools. If you hand a vendor the gatekeeper job a human does, the vendor can be on the hook for how that gate works.
Since then, the case has only gotten bigger… Other applicants over 40 have been able to join, and in June 2026 the judge let most of the remaining claims keep going, disability claims included.
The case is in discovery now so still no verdict. Val walks through every twist and what each ruling actually means on the pod 🎧, so I'll leave the legal play-by-play to the professional.
The tl;dr: "It's the vendor's problem" is not a defense anymore and "we just make the software" isn't one either.
One more detail I can't stop thinking about: in May 2026, the court said some of Workday's bias-testing analysis could stay protected by attorney-client privilege, because lawyers curated the data used for the testing. I find that fascinatingggg. 🙃
BTW: I know what some of you are thinking, “we don't use Workday, so this isn't my problem.”
Not to burst your bubble on this beautiful Monday afternoon but that… is wrong.
TBH to me this case isn't JUST about one vendor. It's about a question every company using AI has to answer: when the tool says no, whose no is it?
Because the candidate doesn't get an email from the algo. They get an email from your company. And here's where it connects to last week!! When the layoff "for AI" didn't work, the cleanup rolled downhill to HR.
✨ Same thing here ✨
When a screening tool goes sideways, nobody calls the vendor's product manager. They call you. You're the one who has to explain a process you may never have been allowed to look inside.
AI didn't create this accountability gap. It just made it faster and quieter in some cases.
HR needs to ask these questions:Copy anchor linkCopied

I know, I know! Sometimes you don't even pick the system you're using. Maybe it was your boss or someone who left like two years ago. And you certainly can’t stop the tech from evolving to include AI or features that you aren’t comfortable with.
And TBH hiring is just where this showed up first. AI is creeping into everything like who gets flagged as a flight risk, who gets a promotion recommendation, what raise the comp tool suggests, even who potentially ends up on the layoff list.
And until more laws get passed around regulation, documentation, use cases, etc we HAVE TO be mindful of who is accountable for the decisions being made.
So here are three questions you CAN ask about ANY tool that touches a people decision, starting this week:
1. Where does a human see the "no"? Map every place a tool can decide something about a candidate or employee on its own. Think:
- Screening out a candidate
- Scoring someone's performance
- Flagging a flight risk
- Suggesting a raise
- Picking names for a RIF
Things like knockout questions count or auto-generated ratings count! If the tool's output goes straight through with nobody checking it, then the tool made that call, not your team.
Everyone on your team should know which people decisions the system makes on its own. Hint: it should be none. I said what I said!
2. What do your vendor contracts say when this goes wrong? Ask every vendor whose tool touches hiring, performance, pay or promotions for their bias audit, and ask who did it and how often. Then sit down with legal and read the contracts together. Who's responsible if a feature gets challenged? Do you even know which AI features are turned on?
3. Are you checking your own numbers? You don't have to wait for the vendor. Wherever a tool makes or shapes the call, look at who comes out the other side. Who's getting screened out, rated lower, passed over for promotion, or flagged? Does it look different by age band or other groups where you have the data?
Closing thoughts:Copy anchor linkCopied

➡️ Last week: if a role is going away "because of AI," know who owns that decision.
➡️ ➡️ This week: if a candidate is going away because of AI, know who owns THAT decision.
The tool can sort. The tool can rank. The tool can send emails in the middle of the night. But it can't be accountable. Only a person can do that.
And if nobody at your company can tell you who that person is... you've found your next project. 😅
Want the legal side? 🎧 Go listen to Val break down Workday plus two SHRM cases on the pod. She makes the legal stuff make sense, and she answers all my silly questions.
Next week, I'm getting sappy. Gratitude edition, in your inbox Thanksgiving week. 🦃
(HUMAN) RESOURCES
- The campaign to bring back Jensen Huang as CEO of Nvidia
- Recognize gets real on Nov 18: who saves HR from being everyone’s punching bag?*
- Why Microsoft went down and what you need to know
- Not the first time Workday has gone down
- Betterment at Work explains 401(k)s without making it weird*
- Sooo many holiday movies coming out this season!
*These are brought to you by my amazing brand partners
WORK-LIFE BALANCE
- 📚 What I’m reading: I, Medusa By Ayana Gray. I’ve kind of, low key, been obsessed with Medusa. I could do a whole Ted Talk on this topic but I’ll refrain. Instead I’ll plug this new release that tells her villain origin story maybe differently than you thought you knew.
- 📺 What I’m watching: Love is Blind Habibi. I spent the first episode trying to guess where everyone was from based on their Arabic accent. I was correct btw. I am a native speaker after all!! My friend Rachel told me I should start dropping Arabic word of the week content into the newsletter, who wants that?!
- 👀 What I’m obsessing over: Thanksgiving recipes!! Am I hosting? No. Do I still plan recipes as if I could or would?? Yeah sometimes!! So send me your fave recipes.
SONG OF THE WEEK
🎧 Aces, Fall Out BoyCopy anchor linkCopied

Your resident emo queen over here!!!!!
FALL OUT BOY IS BACKKKK dropping fresh tracks and infiltrating every second of my day.
Am I seeing them in concert next summer? YOU BETTER BELIEVE IT.
I hope you enjoyed this, please let me know what you think and what other topics you'd love for me to cover. I'm allll ears.
Reminder: Take care of yourself and know that I support you.

